Re: 20 Questions (Vol. IV)

Solitaire Sat May 07, 2011 4:49 pm

The answer to question 4 says this magical thing is not explicitly mentioned in more than one book ...

8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts?

Julia H. Sat May 07, 2011 5:34 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.

Solitaire Sat May 07, 2011 5:46 pm

9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA?

Julia H. Sat May 07, 2011 5:52 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.

Potteraholic Sat May 07, 2011 5:54 pm

10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS?

Julia H. Sat May 07, 2011 5:57 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.

Potteraholic Sat May 07, 2011 6:04 pm

11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary?

Julia H. Sat May 07, 2011 6:18 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.

Solitaire Sat May 07, 2011 6:44 pm

12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets?

Julia H. Sat May 07, 2011 7:29 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.

Solitaire Sat May 07, 2011 8:21 pm

13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? 20 Questions (Vol. IV) - Page 9 Smilie_maulende_myrte2

Julia H. Sun May 08, 2011 8:49 am

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.

Potteraholic Sun May 08, 2011 9:42 am

Hmmm... something explicitly discussed in one book (CoS) but it may well be there in other books, too. What sort of tangible, more than "a thing" could possibly have been at Hogwarts at other times besides in CoS? LOL, no idea! So...

14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson?

Julia H. Sun May 08, 2011 10:21 am

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.
14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson? Yes.

Potteraholic Sun May 08, 2011 10:31 am

15. Is this thing first mentioned before any part of Hallowe'en day?

Julia H. Sun May 08, 2011 11:19 am

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.
14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson? Yes.
15. Is this thing first mentioned before any part of Hallowe'en day? Yes.

Potteraholic Sun May 08, 2011 11:26 am

16. Is this more than "a thing" first mentioned in the chapter where Harry and Ron encounter the Whomping Willow?

Solitaire Sun May 08, 2011 1:26 pm

More than "a thing" ...

17. Is this thing a living thing?

Julia H. Sun May 08, 2011 6:41 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.
14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson? Yes.
15. Is this thing first mentioned before any part of Hallowe'en day? Yes.
16. Is this more than "a thing" first mentioned in the chapter where Harry and Ron encounter the Whomping Willow? No.
17. Is this thing a living thing? No.

Hint: The answer is more than "a" thing. 20 Questions (Vol. IV) - Page 9 2752390508

20 Questions (Vol. IV) - Page 9 2752390508

Solitaire Sun May 08, 2011 11:17 pm

18. Is there more than one of these things at Hogwarts?

Julia H. Mon May 09, 2011 2:56 am

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.
14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson? Yes.
15. Is this thing first mentioned before any part of Hallowe'en day? Yes.
16. Is this more than "a thing" first mentioned in the chapter where Harry and Ron encounter the Whomping Willow? No.
17. Is this thing a living thing? No.
18. Is there more than one of these things at Hogwarts? Yes!

Solitaire Mon May 09, 2011 9:46 am

19. Is it something used in herbology class?

Julia H. Mon May 09, 2011 12:31 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.
14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson? Yes.
15. Is this thing first mentioned before any part of Hallowe'en day? Yes.
16. Is this more than "a thing" first mentioned in the chapter where Harry and Ron encounter the Whomping Willow? No.
17. Is this thing a living thing? No.
18. Is there more than one of these things at Hogwarts? Yes!
19. Is it something used in herbology class? No.

Potteraholic Mon May 09, 2011 3:02 pm

20. Are these things first mentioned in an odd-numbered chapter?

Julia H. Mon May 09, 2011 6:32 pm

1. Is it a person? No.
2. Is it first mentioned before the Triwizard tournament? Yes.
3. Is whatever it is magical? Yes.
4. Is it mentioned in more than one book? Explicitly probably not.
5. Is it a thing? It is more than "a thing".
6. Is it a tangible thing? Yes.
7. Is it a tangible thing that can impart knowledge? No.
8. Is this magical thing something that can be found at Hogwarts? Yes. It is explicitly discussed in one book but it may well be there in other books, too.
9. Is it first discussed/seen in PoA? No.
10. Is it first discussed/seen in CoS? Yes.
11. Is it first mentioned/discussed/seen before Harry enters Tom Riddle's diary? Yes.
12. Is it the Chamber of Secrets? No.
13. Is it something in Moaning Myrtle's bathroom? No.
14. Is it something first mentioned before Lockhart and Snape's duelling demo lesson? Yes.
15. Is this thing first mentioned before any part of Hallowe'en day? Yes.
16. Is this more than "a thing" first mentioned in the chapter where Harry and Ron encounter the Whomping Willow? No.
17. Is this thing a living thing? No.
18. Is there more than one of these things at Hogwarts? Yes!
19. Is it something used in herbology class? No.
20. Are these things first mentioned in an odd-numbered chapter? Yes.

Sponsored content

20 Questions (Vol. IV)